SAPO head publicly names the Security Service as the source of pressure on 'Carthage-2'

Oleksandr Klymenko said that two months before the operation's second stage he was 'strongly recommended' to stop the investigation, and pointed to the SBU. NABU director Semen Kryvonos speaks of 'the most dangerous situation in history'. The names of those who applied pressure are still missing.

On the evening of 17 November, at the forum 'Resilience in Action: People, Rights, State', the head of the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, Oleksandr Klymenko, said publicly for the first time that the investigation into the second stage of Operation Carthage could have been stopped two months before it was carried out. 'On Carthage-2, two months in advance I was, let's put it this way, strongly recommended not to move in that direction, for the investigation to stop. It did not stop,' he said.

Panellists at a forum: four people seated in a row by a table with water bottles, a woman with a microphone speaking; information-partner logos on the screen behind
© Скриншот з відео: мережа ANTS (YouTube), підпис hromadske
Open full-size image

Asked to clarify who exactly had issued the warnings, Klymenko replied: 'From the Security Service, let's put it this way.' He did not name the surnames or positions of those who 'recommended'. The investigation, he said, will continue: 'We will try to establish everyone involved in the activity of these drug cartels, and from the Security Service, let's put it this way.'

NABU director Semen Kryvonos, on the same panel, assessed the position of the anti-corruption bodies after the second round of searches more starkly than ever before: 'We have acquired so many enemies that we are now in the most dangerous situation in our entire history.' Among those hostile to NABU and SAPO he named 'many clans, financial and industrial groups, political forces' who, in his words, will use any opportunity to undermine the bodies' main weapon — public trust.

SAPO head Oleksandr Klymenko in an olive sweater seated at a table with a Ukrainian flag behind him
© Назарій Мазилюк / Українська правда (підпис на сторінці ZMINA)
Open full-size image

Kryvonos also warned of a discrediting campaign whose outlines, he said, are already visible: 'Now all this chatter will begin about Russian influence, about an information operation, other nonsense. Certain political forces and individual politicians are already joining in.' He urged citizens to treat information about the bureau's work critically and promised that the bodies would keep informing the public about the progress of investigations.

The case that gave the bodies 'too many enemies'

On 4 November, NABU and SAPO announced the exposure, within Carthage, of a criminal organisation that, according to investigators, included at least 12 people, among them serving senior officials of the SBU, the Prosecutor General's Office and the National Police, as well as figures from the criminal underworld. It is accused of systematic bribes for the unimpeded operation of scam call centres, of shielding the 'Khimprom' drug cartel, counterfeit cigarettes and forged currency, and of organising attacks, abductions and bodily harm.

Five people were notified of suspicion. The High Anti-Corruption Court ordered pre-trial detention with an alternative bail of UAH 15 million for Volodymyr Tsenov, first deputy head of a National Police department, referred to in the case materials as 'Price'; detention without bail for Vitalii Rybalko ('Boxer'), whom investigators call the organisation's executor of violent crimes; and detention with bail of UAH 65 million for Serhiy Duka, former first deputy head of an SBU department — the bail was paid on 13 November and the general left pre-trial detention. On 18 November the court ordered detention without bail until 16 January for Andrii Osipov ('Kryminal'), whom NABU calls the ringleader of the group.

A man with glasses in a dark suit sits at a table with a small Ukrainian flag, documents and a nameplate reading Semen. NABU Director Semen Kryvonos; archive photo.
© Чулюк-Заграй Микита / Wikimedia Commons
Open full-size image

The state's personnel response to these exposures has been limited to dismissals and suspensions inside the agencies themselves: SBU chief Oleksandr Poklad removed two senior officers of the service who became suspects in the investigation, and the National Police suspended officers against whom detectives had carried out procedural actions. Who exactly, and at what level, 'strongly recommended' stopping the case before the searches was not stated either from the forum stage or in any official statement.

The counter-attack on the investigators

A day before the forum, on 16 November, former Prosecutor General Ruslan Kravchenko accused NABU detectives and SAPO prosecutors of allegedly stealing, during the 4 September searches at the Prosecutor General's Office, the materials of a case concerning people from the close circle of the SAPO head, and published audio recordings he describes as conversations of those people. The authenticity of the recordings has not been independently confirmed. SAPO rejected the accusations: during the September searches no materials of any criminal proceeding were seized, and Kravchenko's statements were assessed as an attempt to influence the Carthage-2 investigation.

File photo: the brick NABU building behind a grey fence, with arched windows and balconies; cars parked in front
© Mr.Rosewater
Open full-size image

On 18 November, the day after Klymenko's statement, SBU major general Serhiy Duka, a suspect in Carthage, presented a counter-version from the podium of the parliamentary Temporary Investigative Commission. He claims that in autumn 2025 the then SBU chief Vasyl Maliuk, after returning from the President's Office, conveyed to him and his deputies an order 'not to move' cases concerning corrupt actions by NABU staff, including bureau director Semen Kryvonos; that the materials for suspicions against Kryvonos had been ready by the end of 2025, but the then Prosecutor General Kravchenko said 'wait' because 'there is no political decision'. Duka also accused NABU and the owner of several media outlets, Tomáš Fiala, of jointly destabilising the country and creating levers of influence over the president, conceding when the commission chair asked: 'I have no facts, but I have gone through this path myself.'

According to Duka, on the day of the commission hearing the SBU suspended the officers who had been running the cases against NABU and SAPO. Thus the story now contains two incompatible versions of the same autumn of 2025: in the Carthage investigators' version, law enforcement officers shielded criminal business; in the suspect general's version, those same proceedings were an instrument of pressure that was slowed down from above. Neither has been tested in court.

A question without names

The SAPO head's statement is a public accusation against an institution subordinate to the same government, made by the body investigating a case involving its serving and former officials. But it remained without names: neither the level, nor the form of the 'recommendation', nor the positions of its authors were disclosed. As of the evening of 18 November the SBU had not publicly responded to either Klymenko or Kryvonos. No one has borne political responsibility for the attempt to stop the investigation either: the only confirmed decisions are personnel purges inside the agencies after the searches and hearings in the investigative commission, where suspects now present their own version.

A light multi-storey building with columns and a pediment bearing Ukraine's coat of arms; a state flag on the roof, a cobbled street with traffic cones in front. Archive photo of the Security Service of Ukraine headquarters building on Volodymyrska Street in Kyiv, 28 April 2018.
© Andrew Milligan sumo / Wikimedia Commons
Open full-size image

The context adds weight to the price of this statement. On 14 November President Volodymyr Zelensky said that NABU and SAPO have no data on links between Health Minister Viktor Liashko, RNBO secretary Ihor Klymenko and 'Servant of the People' faction head Davyd Arakhamia and the Carthage suspects, and promised further personnel changes. Earlier, on 15 September, parliament dismissed Ruslan Kravchenko as prosecutor general after NABU's searches at the Prosecutor General's Office and his announcement of a suspicion against the NABU director; on 2 November the SBI closed the proceeding against Kryvonos.

Klymenko promised that the investigation would establish everyone involved — including those who came 'from the Security Service'. Whether those names will appear in the case file rather than only in quotes from a forum, and whether the accusation against an entire security service of pressuring an investigation will receive a public answer, is a question the next episodes of Carthage must answer with documents, not with podiums.

Fact checking

Primary sources

Documents and statements this story is based on.